Theo's

The horror of illegal immigrants and phentinyl flooding the open borders almost washes away in the quaint town of Newcomerstown, which is dressed to the hilt in Christmas cheer. Theo's creamed chicken, fish & chips and pies are amazing. Now if something would be done about securing the borders, it could be a really good day.

I've been in Cambridge for 3 years now. I've placed several orders and have never had an issue until today. The young lady who took my ordered asked for my card number 3 times which had never happened to me before. She thought it was funny to repeat my card number wrong then apologize. I've never been nervous about using my card with Theo's before today. I hope this was just a one time event and nothing happens with my card. I like the fact that you guys deliver so I frequent this restaurant alot. I hope my next experience is alot better than this!!!

My wife and I stopped by Theo's on a recommendation from a local. The food was great. The service, not so much. We were seated right away. It took a little while for our waitress to come by, but we had to look at the menu anyway. My wife ordered an Iced Tea and a Brisket Burger. I got a Cherry Dr Pepper and the Brisket Burger, which was a special that day for lunch. We told the waitress we'd probably want pie for dessert. We got our drinks, and then our waitress brought our burgers and drink refills out shortly after. The burgers and fries were very good and cooked perfectly. Long after we were finished, we were looking for our waitress to order pie. She was nowhere to be found. Being the smart donkey that I am, I called the restaurant and said: "I'd like to order a couple pieces of pie, to be delivered... to my table." The guy that answered said he'd find my waitress. We finally got our pie. I had the Banana Cream, and my wife had coconut cream. They were both very good and nice sized pieces. The guy that answered the phone seemed like he was upset with me, but really, he should look at why I had to call. Just to be clear, I took pictures of our food because I always review new places. The pictures of the pie were a half hour after the burgers. My phone call was over 20 minutes after we got our food. That's how long it had been since we'd seen our waitress. The food was excellent. But the service could have been a lot better, including the response to my phone call. I would still recommend this place because of the menu and the quality of the food.

A friend who is highly allergic to our cats suggested we meet here. I've dined here once before. It's definitely a hometown restaurant specializing in American food. The 2 breaded fish portions were huge & the fries were okay. The chef's salad was huge with plenty of ham but was made with iceberg lettuce. Theo's is known for its pies, but I didn't really care for the crust. I didn't share these thoughts with my 3 male companions. ;)

We were in in town for the Courthouse light show as well as shopping at all of the local town stores. This restaurant came highly recommended by many store employees and online reviews. We were NOT disappointed. as a matter of fact we were extremely happy that we took everyone's advice. The restaurant was very clean and the employees were amazing. From the hostess to our server we were very well taken care of. We were seated very quickly and our server, Drew, took our drink orders. We chose our dinners and were served a great meal in short order. I was skeptical at first of the prices I saw on the online menu and thought they must have been from a few years before and not recently updated. I was really surprised that their prices were the same really reasonable prices that I saw online. The food was amazing, and the pies were worth all of the talk that we heard from everyone all over town. I told our small group that if this restaurant was near my town that I would come here at least 6 to 10 times a month. What a great place !!!!

Hannah was our waitress this afternoon during our first visit to Theo's. She was pleasant, efficient and checked back with us several times to make sure we had all we needed. I would recommend Theo's Resturant to anyone living in the Cambridge area or visitors like us who enjoyed our meal and the reasonable pricing.