The Railpenny Tavern

I had one of the best meals. It was my first time going and it was recommended to me. Great hospitality is the worst way to describe how amazing the staff was. My waitress was attentive and sweet and funny. She just made me feel comfortable and excited about my choices. She was fantastic. I can't wait to go again!

This was our first time here, and we enjoyed the environment. We sat at the bar and could tell this is one of those places where ' everybody knows your name's. The bartender seemed to know almost everyone who came in, and was very friendly and welcoming to us. We decided to have dinner there and stayed at the bar. Neither of us really cared much for the meals we each got. There were too many conflicting spices and/or seasonings, etc going on in each of our meals. I had the fried chicken sandwich and they were too many sauces, seasonings, etc. on that sandwich for my liking, so much so that I couldn't taste the actual chicken. The hand-cut fries were delicious. My husband had the French dip sandwich, tavern fries, and a small cup of chili. He enjoyed the chili and the fries, but not so much the sandwich due to some seasonings, etc. they use. We both felt this restaurant was a little on the pricey side for what we got. It was pretty busy the evening we were there, and I imagine service at the bar might be a little more attentive when it's not as busy. We had to wait too long for the bartender to notice that I needed a beer refill. We had 1 glass of house wine and 2 draft beers. Our bill was just under $70.00 - a little pricey in our opinion.

We didn't expect the food to be as truly wonderful as it was..... we saw "tavern" and thought pub food, wow, were we wrong! The menu was well rounded, the atmosphere lively, and the service was the best we've had since before the pandemic! Rachel had great insight & epic timing. She managed all 5 courses beautifully.... we had never been, so we tried a little of everything. The Cobb salad had a house made deviled egg on it, the chili had venison, the entrees were PERFECTLY cooked & the deserts- house made and delicious. Kudos to the kitchen staff for thier brilliance & expeditors who made sure that as soon as the dish was plated, it was soon to be in front of us! We will definitely be back.