Godfather's Pizza

Don't let the look of the pizza fool you! I always enjoy Goffather's... let alone pizza. But the last two visits my pizza has been very bland and the crust is really hard. The pizza truthfully hasn't been good at all....Now true Godfather's lovers know the crust is the best part of the pizza and mine both times have been to hard to eat... I think this is my last go at it. But the gentlemen are great! The place was clean to be inside of a gas station, I appreciate the kindness and the reason for 2 stars! Last they are really expensive... But that's across the board, not just this location.

Every pizza I have gotten from Godfathers has been absolutely perfect! From the toppings to the crust it has been perfect!!! Good work Mike Glassmyer and your entire team!! I would recommend to anybody!!! Delicious pies all day long!! It is a bit pricey but...for the quality you get, it is totally worth it! They don't skimp at all!!! And cooked perfectly every time!! Thanks to Mike and his crew!! Keep up the good work!!

I love their pizza. It’s one of my favorites in town. It can be pricey but they also have nice deals during the week. I had a pizza out for delivery and the guy that was on the phone was nice and friendly but they need to make sure they say the total before asking for your card. I asked how much the total was and it was more than I wanted to spend so he had to go back and start over. He didn’t seem mad though. He didn’t tell me the new total either. All in all I love their pizza and it’s in a decent location in town. They just need to focus on saying their totals.

I was very shocked to see a pizza buffet in the middle of a Gas Station with I think 2 other restaurants, it was just weird, however, I loved this place, the people are what made this place the best, then was the meatballs, I have had a lot of meatballs in my day and I mean a lot, but this place is hands down the BEST!!! When I come back to Hastings this is what I will eat, the meatballs, the taste of the meatballs are something I NEVER ever had before, it was just perfect! The people again are the reason it was a great place, wish they had one with the same people here in Ohio! God Bless!

Ordered two medium pizzas from here total was 40$ ..Wow steak dinner price). Asked for specials was told there was none. Looked online there was several! Told manager would call me, had to call back next day..talked to owner manager who was tough on the phone lied to me told he heard nothing of my issue then later stated oh yeah know all about it! From outta town at girls state softball, they need to move to a more accommodating town. Very dissatisfied I hope no one goes to this establishment will report to the BBB.

Placed a delivery order, first time ordering with Godfather's, had to ask what the specials were, no suggestive selling. Didn't tell me the amount of my order, before he asked me my payment information, very unprofessional. Good thing l had a great delivery person. Need to work on telephone skills.