Italian
Pizza
Sit down

Stay updated about Goodfellas Italian Restaurant's offers

Sluurpy's certification

Certificate of excellence (Sluurpy)
Make a reservationMake a reservation
Order onlineOrder online
Find RestaurantFind the best restaurant in Rotherham
94
/100
Based on 652 parameters and reviews
Updated 2020-02-21
Tripadvisor
Tripadvisor
5,0
377 Reviews
Upd.

21/02/2020

Google
Google
4,8
100 Reviews
Upd.

15/11/2019

Facebook
Facebook
4,9
111 Reviews
Upd.

08/01/2020

Y

Yell.com
4,0
4 Reviews
Upd.

22/10/2019

The Chef reccomendThe Chef reccomend

  • Pesto
  • Calamari
  • Meatballs
  • Calamares
  • Lamb
  • Pasta
  • Fish
  • Tiramisu
  • Risotto
  • Lasagne
  • Prawns
  • Salmon

Description

  • Phone number: +44 1709 837373
  • Cuisine:
    Italian
    ,
    Vegetarian Friendly
    ,
    Vegan Options
    ,
    Gluten Free Options
    ,
    Pizza
  • Restrictions:
    Vegan Options
    ,
    Gluten Free Options
    ,
    Vegetarian Friendly
  • Meal types:
    Dinner
    ,
    Lunch
  • Category:
    Sit down


Reviews

  • Logo
    659warwicka 2020-02-08

    The food was exceptional, traditional Italian cooked the way it should be & good portion sizes. Staff were all very friendly & attentive throughout. Can’t fault a thing about the restaurant, the only thing we were short of was time as we booked late.

  • Logo
    DaveW552 2020-01-29

    A fantastic evening , great food , great company and great service , very friendly and competent waiter and a top owner from Sicily ! My salmon special was excellent as were the Lasagnes and my sons pizza was his best one yet . We shall return !

  • Logo
    J10SWE 2020-01-29

    Visited as walk in prior to attending NY Stadium for football match. Located nearby. Time of the essence, seated and served quickly. Friendly service and great food. Our team lost so this was this best bit of our trip up north! Recommended.

  • Logo
    Senora2000 2020-01-10

    I visited in the week with my adult children. Beautiful tasty food , excellent service and lovely atmosphere. My son had steak and loved it and me and girls had pasta dishes .. all highly recommended. Will be returning!

  • Logo
    CH2287 2019-12-19

    We visited for the second time last night for our girls Christmas meal, and once again it was lovely. All the staff are so friendly and welcoming. The food again was superb and the portions are huge!!! We shall certainly be visiting again in the New Year :-)

  • Logo
    MeAndonis 2019-11-18

    Another superb meal,managed to book a table for my wife and friends to celebrate a birthday.As usual the food was outstanding.All the party enjoyed their meals the service was superb as usual.

  • Logo
    Venny45 2019-10-30

    Our first visit but it certainly won’t be the last! We had a wide range of dishes and all were delicious, the service was fantastic so friendly and welcoming, can’t believe we haven’t visited before.

  • Logo
    Janet K 2019-10-19

    Not been here for a good few years and we were not disappointed at all . The meals all 5 were fabulous we all ate everything and couldn’t fault it the service was very attentive too what’s not to love

  • Logo
    terry57Retford_UK 2019-10-05

    Visited with friends and having read the reviews was really looking forward to our visit. Lovely friendly greeting and atmosphere in this small cosy restaurant. Service very good and certainly not rushed. The big disappointment was my steak, ordered the fillet pepper steak, medium rare, and one of our friends ordered the same but medium. When they arrived mine was well done at least. I hoped that it was just overdone on the outside but as I progressed through it, it just got more and more well done. I pointed this out to the manager, who to be fair, offred to prepare another but as the rest of our party were well into their meals I chose to decline and he did take it off the bill, so no complaints about how this was dealt with. But surely, a restauarant of this standard knows how to cook a steak. The waitress said she had misheard me and ordered it medium, and if it had been served medium (ie pink in the middle) I would have eaten it but it was cooked all the way through (well done). Shame. Having said all of the above I think we would visit again but maybe stick to the pasta dishes which looked better prepared.

  • Logo
    172amandaw 2019-10-04

    Visited for a Friday dinner, as usual amazing food, service and choice. My fave restaurant. Nothing is too much trouble, it truly is a fabulous place to eat.....thank you!

  • Logo
    ddbrross 2019-09-08

    Went last night for sons birthday, friendly staff, lovely food, big portions but service rather slow. House wine was good too.All in all value for money just need to speed up service a little

  • Logo
    Kirstyloux 2019-09-07

    I have been to this Italian once before a few years ago & it was gorgeous, so me & my partner came again tonight on the 7.9.19, we had a table booked for 6 & was a little early but this wasn’t a problem! We was seated straight away & given a warm welcome by all staff! Our drinks orders were taken quickly & we were given enough time to choose our food! The garlic bread starter was amazing! So fresh! I had linguine with meatballs & this wasn’t even on the menu but there was no issue with making me this at all & in all honesty it was the best pasta dish I have ever tasted! The sauce was amazing! My partner had a pizza & he said this was also amazing! The staff literally cannot do enough for you! They are all so lovely & friendly! This is now our favourite restaurant & will certainly be back very soon!!

  • Logo
    CH2287 2019-09-05

    We visited Goodfellas last night for the first time after hearing really good reviews about the place and it certainly lived up to them. The service from start to finish was excellent and the man looking after us was so friendly and he couldn't do enough for us. The food was all delicious and the menu has plenty of options on even for vegetarians. I'd definitely recommend, and we shall certainly be visiting again soon.

  • Logo
    John S 2019-08-26

    We visit this restaurant at least once a month usually more because it is such an enjoyable experience. The food is freshly prepared and from our visits to Italy it appears authentic Italian.. Because the owner, Marchello and Josephina, lead the front of house the service is personal a friendly. The long time head chef (Hungarian) prepares consistently good dishes. House wine is good (Marchello would not offer something he would not drink himself) and reasonably priced so we very rarely drink anything else. We have been as a family (four generations) and just the two of us. Always a pleasure!.

  • Logo
    pauldeb64 2019-08-26

    This is our go to restaurant. Lovely owners and staff where nothing is too much trouble. Excellent food with a varied menu and additional specials. House red wine is gorgeous, a little too much if truth be told. Will keep going back. Highly recommended call in you won’t be sorry

  • Logo
    105lucy123 2019-08-24

    Have been coming here for a while now, never disappoints with food! Only gets better! Food is stunning EVERYTIME! Staff are lovely, attentive and friendly. Such a nice quiet relaxing atmosphere. Price of food is also exceptionally good considering the top quality of the meals! My favourite place to eat and would recommend to anybody!

  • Logo
    davidb24816 2019-08-23

    Just had the most fabulous meal and the staff were very polite and attentive.I would definitely recommend Goodfellas Italian to anyone.

  • Logo
    Chris W 2019-08-20

    As a group of friends we visit this family operated restaurant as often as we can...I always ask for items off the menu and they are happy to accommodate. We prefer a table upstairs although the atmosphere on the ground floor is always vibrant. Can't wait until we go again !

  • Logo
    MeAndonis 2019-08-17

    Managed to get a table for six and our party was delighted with the food as usual.Went with two other couples to my favourite restaurant ,one couple had been before and knew what a high standard to expect.The other couple travelled from the far side of Bawtry they were really impressed with the high quality food and wine .The service ,food (we had five different mains several different starters and desserts between us),and wine were all superb.From the arrival to the fairwell the whole evening was superb.We discovered that the owners were to have a short holiday back home in Sicily starting the following Monday so were doubly delighted to get in.Hope they had a well deserved rest our friends from Bawtry said that they cannot wait to go again.

  • Logo
    Caterina A 2019-08-08

    This is by far the best Italian restaurant! The staff are welcoming and always happy. The food is excellent and a good choice with specials that change every week. Great house wines, fab desserts the tiramisu is really special. Good value for money.

Restaurants in Rotherham

Our aggregate rating, “Sluurpometro”, is 94 based on 652 parameters and reviews

If you need to contact by phone, call the number +44 1709 837373

Timetable:

  • Monday
  • Tuesday 18:00-22:00
  • Wednesday 18:00-22:00
  • Thursday 18:00-22:00
  • Friday 18:00-22:30
  • Saturday 18:00-22:30
  • Sunday

1