Windy City Pie

Delicious pizza (4 ⭐️). A little too much bread for me, but legit may be the best pizza sauce I’ve ever had. Smooth, slightly sweet, robust ripe tomato flavor. The thin crust was perfect. Drinks were awesome (hot toddy please!). The Chicago pizzas were delicious and worth trying. I’ll order little more cheese/sauce/toppings next time. Texture of the crust was great too. This is a 4.5 star review all things considered.

Awesome pie! I have never been to the Windy City but if the pies here represent the Windy City, I need to go! We had the Beers by Shrute salad and the Mama Mia pie- The people here were very friendly and recognized prior customers. I also had the traditional shot of malört- which kinda reminds me of absinthe and the night was memorable!

A very different deep dish pizza typically when I think of deep dish the sauce is the star of the show however, this pizza is very very doughy. I got the pepperoni and it is very similar to pizza from Central market now town and country if you go here, you have to get the tavern pizza it is far better than the deep dish. Just had another pie on 10/29/23 seems to be if you order a full pepperoni pie it’s more Chicago style however still very very bready. Just know that when ordering. The thin crust is nice.

Great place!! I’m on a quest for decent pizza in Seattle, and this place definitely was a hit! When I saw that they had Chicago style thin crust and not just deep dish, I suspected I might have found a gem of a place, and I was right! Yes I’m from Chicago, and if you are too then you know most pizza places in Chicago are not deep dish, nevertheless Chicago has its own style of thin crust, and it’s my favorite pizza. I had the sausage and giardiniera pizza which is a classic combo for me. It’s a little on the spicy side and they put basil and parmesan on top of it which struck me as odd, but the pizza was excellent!! The crust was also a little too airy for Chicago style; but I don’t want to nitpick. The server was friendly and not a hipster and that’s already 5 million times better than your average Seattle pizza place. Restaurant is on top of a hill right next to a zoo and a park with sweeping views of the lakes and mountains on a clear day. Interior was cozy and well decorated and felt warm and inviting. The pizza was on the smaller side but very rich and not particularly expensive. I will be back here for SURE!