Andy's Supper Club

I always grade on a curve and this place is solid 4 star for small town restaurants. Was staying overnight and came here at the direction of a local and was not disappointed. Food was solid, menu diverse, and I really liked the ambiance- the kind of place you'd think John Gustafson would have taken Ann Truax on a first date.

Stopped in for New Years Eve dinner. Seemed like they needed 1-2 more people working so they weren't running around with their heads cut off. Ladies who worked there were all very nice and attentive. Was not as busy as they made it seem, had told us they only have one table left due to holiday. Soda is from bar key and not fountain machine. Prices were high for kids meals and small portions, almost $10 each. Adult meals were more expensive, larger portions. Good quality, prices still higher than necessary for dive bar/grill. Clean atmosphere and warm inside on cold night. Would come back!

This is a comfortable bar-and-grill type place where families are welcome to eat. We've eaten here a few times without reservations in groups of 8-10 for lunch or early dinner after my grandson's ball games, but during busy times like on weekends or special occasions you'd definitely need to make reservations. The menu is not extensive, but the basics are covered, and they serve some fine Mayfield (a local place known for its high standards of meat processing) steaks as well as decent seafood. Since it is a bar, you can imbibe along with your meal if you choose. Our meals are usually decent to excellent, and I would consider this restaurant to be very good for this area. One odd thing: the women's bathroom stalls are tiny and last time I was there, one didn't have a curtain!