Cafe Sitaly

I was sadly disappointed. I've been craving fries and a chicken Cheesesteak all-day. The fries were overcooked, and The chicken cheesesteak had a fish taste. This is the second time I'm ordering this, and both times, the fries have looked and tasted overcooked, and some of them were soaked with oil. Overall, I hope this won't happen again as I have enjoyed their other foods🥰

My go to pizza joint. Best pizza around hands down. Fries can be soggy which is disappointing. The fry bags they use do not keep hot- just make them soggy. Pasta dishes are incredible, but way too expensive. Staff is nice. The wait is typical. They’ve messed up an order for me once, but easily fixed my problem. Interior of Cafe Sitaly feels so crammed & a bit unclean. No where to wait for an order. All in all, I am satisfied with the food. They could really benefit from expanding into a larger location!

Here I am with all thoughts on ordering a meal for my family for delivery which I always get from here! To find out only pizza or strobili! Told them I would wait an hr or so! Said no! Well as much as I patronize this place and my family! Done!!! You can't run a biz like that! Very disappointed!! Never in my life have I ever heard this!! Va fun goul!!!

I have to say, this is top notch Italian food. The place is small but the flavor here is amazing and you really feel like family. I love the atmosphere and you can take food to go. Even though you most likely will have to wait a bit for a table or booth, it’s 100% worth it because the food is delicious. There is a family restroom and a single person men’s room and they are very clean. I highly recommend this place if you are looking for quality Italian cuisine!

Good food should taste good and also BE good - as in healthy, and they nailed it. I had a veal Cacciatore with a side of garlic knots and it came with a side salad. They use ingredients that are both fresh and of good quality as is a must for good taste. The tomato sauce they use is made from tomatoes with no extra gooey fillers so it sits light and soaks well into the linguini with no sticky consistency. Veal was tender, linguini was aldente( Mine got a little soft cause i picked it up 20 mins late, but still by no means overcooked). If you order out, get your food fast so the pasta doesn't soften while sitting. Garlic knots were tasty and tender. The marinara dipping sauce was verrrry delicious- u really must try it. I got a sausage pepperoni slice that was delicious too. the crust cooked just right with a hint of cruchiness, Not too thick or too think or too crunchy(most places can't get this right :(.  They use good cheese and toppings and real tomato sauce. I think the quality ingredients and good culinary sense really sets this shop apart. The restaurant sits at a strip mall by the corner of Marsh and Naamans and they are quite easy to miss but once you eat their you will be sorry for all the times you sped by to catch the light. They have some booth and table sittings that look classy, like someone put a little thought into it. On the whole it is a solid Italian eatery to patronize. The icing on the cake is that they are fairly affordable at mid-lower pricing. You can feed the beast well without breaking the bank.