Bexley Pizza Plus

So today was my first experience with this pizza. And I must say it’s a yes for me order the supreme with cheesy bread it’s a yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes!!!! Baaaaayyyy baaaaaaayyy this crust!!!! Yes Lord!!!! Father God we thank you for the individuals who made this heavenly pizza 🍕 it was gone in 15mins amen lord bless them with more and even more customers in Jesus name amen 🙏🏾

Use to be pretty excited about this place until recently they decided to stop taking orders or even picking up the phone a half an hour before closing... If you stop taking orders or answering your phone at 8:30. Advertise that your closed at 8:30. If it says your open until 9, stay open until 9. The past few times I've tried to order from here there's been issues as well, so starting ordering from Gahanna pizza plus. Really enjoy the pizza plus pizza, just don't really enjoy this Bexley location.

This was my second visit to Bexley Pizza Plus. I first visited soon after one of their people won an international pizza contest. I feel about the same about this visit as the first. Their pizza is good, but not great (IMHO). They DO excel with service. The phone order taker was efficient but friendly. The cashier had a great smile and was quick with his processes. The pizza came out of the kitchen almost exactly when they said it would be ready, and it is very close to my house, so very convenient To my dismay, the pizza was a bit less extraordinary. I ordered the Maximum Pepperoni and Philly Cheesesteak pizzas this time around. The "max pep" had a good amount of pepperoni and was pleasantly spicy but lacked moisture - there was a miniscule amount of sauce and the crust was a bit dry and "blah". The white pizza with "Philly steak" did not suffer from the dryness of the red model, but there was barely enough steak to have a small sample of meat on each piece. To me, it tasted good but could have been better. The verdict from me is it is more than OK, but there are better options. My preference is probably more "Columbus Style", similar to Donato's, Massey's or Tommy's, so if that is not your thing, perhaps this institution's product will appeal to you more than it did to me.

And the winner is...Bexely Pizza Plus. As a teenager, young adult is drop in here to have a bite after a jog thru the neighborhood where I'd pretend I owned one of the mini mansions and was waiting for friends to join me. I eventually purchased a home, in the Historic Bryden area, foryears after graduating high school, got married, had children and this is now the place I either pick up a personal pizza to go and eat in my car or dine in and share memories with My children, (notsomuchsonow) or meet adult friends. My favorite thing to order then was the greek pizza and now I'm sort of a plain pepperoni knind of girl. It's loud friendly, they have high chairs, and local and domestic adult beverages and fountain drinks. They employee teens or young adults that have the right attitude and make it a great place to continue to visit.