Pi Squared Pizza Tavern

Love this place! We went in finally for the first time in the fall when we didn’t have all the kids (prefer to try new places alone). We got the thin crust pizza and they had a deal that gave us free garlic knots. The pizza was delicious and the garlic knots were the best I have had in Denton! Oh my gosh they are soo good! I joined the text message program for specials offers and deals and we got a text on Pi day that was buy one pizza get the second $3.14. What a steal! We went in and got the same pizza I think, plus a Detroit style. Oh my! That Detroit pizza is my new fav! It’s extremely filling too. Between those two pizzas and the garlic knots (cannot pass those up ever) we had leftovers for days. We’ve ordered them to go during this Covid-19 pandemic. They never disappoint! Go in and get on their text offerings.

I have eaten here several times. Expect to have square pizzas with satisfying flavor. Has a small bar with a variety of beer and wine on tap. Bottles are available too. Alone? Then watch the game. Both sandwiches and pizza have been great, but there is a little secret I want to tell you. Come closer, closer. The garlic twist rolls melt in your mouth. You don't really need that sauce. Put it aside. Take a bite of that buttery garlic bread, sit back, smile and savor.

DO NOT WASTE YOUR MONEY OR TIME!!! Listen up everyone, PSA! This place has HORRIBLE service!! There is NO management, the staff is overwhelmed and understaffed ALL THE TIME..etc. I have been here a handful of times and have noticed a decline in the service with each visit. Tonight I took my family who was in from out of town, big mistake. We called 20 min ahead of time (by the way its always a huge gamble if they will even pick the phone up or not when you call) this very sweet girl took our order over the phone and said it would be 30 min. We show up and wait for over an HOUR! We were being told every 10 min "just 5-10 more minutes and your pizza will be finished." By the way we ordered 2 small pizzas and a COLD ham and cheese sub...? When the food was presented to us (we only received one pizza and the sub) the pizza had two pepperonis, some cheese missing, and WAS COLD?! The girl in the front was so sweet, apologetic and helpful you could tell she was very overwhelmed, where is the owner of this place and or management? Someone needs to roll their sleeves up and get in there when their staff is drowning! Needless to say we left the place with NO pizzas because the ONE we received looked disgusting, was cold but we did bring home the sub for my Mom... see photo in comments. Thank GOD for Dominos tonight!

Pleasantly surprised to find that a new pizza place in Denton has such a different approach. Manager Lauren is fantastic with customer service. My wife and I tried the 7" midwest style veggie lovers and the Detroit-style specialty Luau pizza. Both were delicious. Garlic knot rolls are addictive. We walked out with enough leftovers to feed us the entire week! Highly recommend.