Started with breakfast Sunday morning. Delicious dairy free porridge with nuts and fruit. We were very impressed with the service, staff very helpful. We decided to book for Sunday lunch and try their grass fed beef . This proved to be the right decision. Fantastic meal with good choice of beers. Despite being very busy the staff were very attentive, we felt we were being treated like celebrities. Although we live approx 170 miles away I am sure we will go back there. Thanks to everyone there , what a great team.
Really good food and service - and a great place to have a party. The food was excellent, and the staff attentive when needed. Would definitely go again.
Good location; the place is very welcoming and the food is good. The atmosphère is very warm and the place it is good to hear a portuguese people in the typical english pub. :) To recommended for good time with friends.
Our first visit to The Star and Garter was born from necessity. We were thirty miles from home on a miserable Sunday afternoon, hungry, and with a newly acquired wine rack taking over the back two-thirds of the car . Its on these occasions that comfort is called for. Long roasted meats with burnished veg and crisp potatoes are the needs of the day. We choose the pub because it has good form; we use their sister pub, The Highfield, as our local go to stop when such needs occur closer to home. There the plate is prettily stacked with carbs, protein, and topped with a fist sized Yorkshire pudding. There are greens to share in a bowl and replacement spuds and Yorkshire puddings are offered. Sundays at The Highfield have never let us down, meaning expectations at The Star and Garter are high.
The Sunday Roast was delicious and very generous portions. When the staff check back on you, they offer you more yorkies and roast potatoes! The service was great! We were greeted immune by Eve, and she served us, got us drinks asap. Also, they're dog friendly. Highly recommend it for an amazing and chill Sunday.
We are big fans of the Peach Pubs group having previously eaten a few times at both The Town House and The One Elm, often on special occasions, as was this one. We did feel that The Star and Garter did not quite match up to their sister pubs in terms of the personal service. Although we had said it was a big birthday celebration, with our children gathering from across the country, there was no acknowledgement of that at all, even when cards and gifts were exchanged. Perhaps this was just because it was a busy Saturday, which also meant that food came a little slowly (even allowing for the fresh cooking).
Having said that, the menu was interesting and varied, including options for the vegan guest, and the food chosen was very tasty and much enjoyed by all 6 of us. There was a real buzz about the place creating a good atmosphere and the staff were knowledgeable, friendly and helpful.
Lovely pub for a sunday roast.
My family really enjoyed the Lamb pavé.
The stuffing was delicious.
Extra point for the possibility to have more Yorkshire pudding and roast potatoes! Very nice touch.
I was a bit disappointed with the shallots tatin , the pastry could have been more cooked/crispy.
The truffle and macaroni cheese was delicious but such a small portion.
Overall, a good meal. I will be back to try more on the menu 😉
Very pleasant evening with ex-work colleagues.
Great food and service.
Perfect Sunday roast here today! The service was impeccable. Great meat and veggie option - food was delicious! Love that you get a jug of gravy and extra yorkies/spuds. The wine and the apple crumble were also exceptional.
Plenty of seating outside with partitioning around from pavement.
Outside service no problem !! with people round regularly checking on you .
Also outside heaters.
Not to busy.
Went back last night (April 2023) not been in for ages . Still very popular a lot of people taking their dogs in with them making a warm welcoming environment for groups to meet up
Nice welcome, excellent knowledgeable and quick service. Great selection. Love how they bring the 'specials board' to your table.
Lovely food.
Overall a really nice friendly place, with great food, drinks and service.
Great staff and a very good Sunday roast. Good menu. Efficient and very friendly service. Highly recommended!
This is one of my locals. I often meet people there for lunch and I've even eaten there by myself when I Just Can't Be Bothered to cook. Staff always welcoming. Food good. Lovely place.
Loved this place!
Went here for a Sunday lunch and it was brilliant. Really tasty comfort food at a decent price. The Sunday roast was great and the black pudding scotch egg (pictured) was a thing of beauty! 🤤
All the staff were really friendly despite running around as it was so busy.
Would definitely recommend to others.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Leamington Spa
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes