Sal's Authentic New York Pizza

The pizza is perfect. The dough is chewy and perfectly baked. The crust is nice and thin, a quality I love on pizzas. The toppings are fresh. My favourite and go-to right now is the classic Manhattan pizza which consists of pepperoni and mushroom. The sauce is great too. I rate the pizza 5/5. I’ve tried the garlic knots, they’re edible and okay tasting but I wouldn’t buy it nor do I recommend it so I’d say it’s a 1/5. (No photo attached) The pepperoni swirls (photo attached) are like little pizza scrolls. I rate them a 4/5 as I’m surprised by the great taste fitted in these mini pastries. Unfortunately the bottom was burnt and I had the burnt taste in my mouth which is something that could be easily fixed. The store is unfortunately too small but it does add a sense of coziness so I don’t mind. The only problem is it’s not ventilated as it should be for a pizza bakery and especially during winter when the front door is closed the smoke gets trapped in. I recommend one additional staff whose only role is cleaning the tables and floors, as there are 3 guys I see at all times who bake and take the orders but usually are too busy to tend to the dine in area. Sal’s Pizza offers wholehearted and unforgettable pizza dishes, and will always be a personal favourite filled with good memories and happy tummies. Follow me in my journey as I try to become one of the best food reviewers of Melbourne ❤️ Thank you.

For all those pizza lovers out there this is your place! We actually loved it so much we came back the next day! We only tried the pepperoni but that in itself was enough to hit the spot. The crust was perfect (I don’t like it too thick) and the sauce was very flavoursome, plus a great amount of cheese and pepperoni. Very reasonably priced too. Would highly recommend to friends and family!

Got there on Saturday night at 8:30pm and it was busy but we were able to get a table. The staff were friendly and all smiles. We got a pepperoni and garlic knots. LOVED the garlic knots with Sal's legendary sauce. I could have had another serving of it. The pepperoni pizza was HUGE. There is something about the pizza base that made it taste great. After adding parmesan and oregano flakes, the topping worked for me. Definitely will come back for the garlic knots and Sal's legendary sauce!

Oh my goodness! I finally got a chance to try Sal's Pizza and I was so happy and impressed! It's so tasty, the Sal's Famous combo was a great foot in the door, a slice of Cheese and Pepperoni, both were super delicious. If you get a chance, or next time you're in Melbourne, hit up a Sal's Pizza, go by yourself or with friends, they cater for both, and it's close to Flinders station so a great location too

The best pizza ever! Period. It’s a very small pizza joint which has been inspired by a New York pizza joint. Not a great dine experience but their Nonna pizza is the best as it can get. Get a takeaway and enjoy your movie night. They even have single slices for smaller appetites. My friends ordered the chicken wings which they absolutely disliked.

Great New York style pizza for reasonable price. Sal's legendary sauce goes well with garlic knots. Keep in mind that the restaurant does not accept card, but you can order online using card and it'll usually be ready for pickup within 15 minutes (even if the estimated pickup time says it could be longer).