Gorgeous little village pub, pays to book to be on the safe side as its very popular but we were early so there was plenty of room for us. Been here a couple of times now and have never been disappointed with the food. Everything is homemade including the desserts. This time both my parter and I had the steak pie with veg and chips. The pie is always full of filling and the pastry is lovely, with a jug of gravy on the side.
The staff are lovely and told us about their takeaway cheesecakes when we said how full we were. Would be rude not to so we took a slice of rocky road cheesecake home and wow! Just as amazing as the meals.
Definitely one of our favourite local places to eat.
Arrived early 12.15 started filling up quickly would recommend booking in advance, when I asked what's the pies like the bartender replied "best pies in the world" now a pretty bold statement I must admit it was absolutely amazing really enjoyed it probably best pub food you can get. Also had the chicken strips they was very tasty tasted homemade pretty sure everything on menu is. Really nice atmosphere and layout scenery inside an out beautiful so lucky to be close by will be coming back here... ALOT! Thank you
Went for a family dinner and it was amazing. Food was all homemade and definitely better than average. The drinks were also great. Had asked for a gin and tonic to find they had 14 different gins available and a great selection of tonic waters. Highly recommend this place.
We've been a couple of times for a meal and the food was excellent as was the service. I decided to book for a family Sunday lunch recently and we couldn't have been happier. Everything cooked to perfection and plenty of it too. You'd be hard pressed to find a better place to enjoy a meal and drink locally.
A big thank you to all at The Bay Horse for all you do.
Just been for a lovely meal with the family to celebrate my wife's birthday. Not been for a long time but was greatly impressed with what we had. We ordered our drinks first and then sat down to choose from the menu, the days specials board was also presented. We ordered 2 pies, 2 hunters chicken and a chicken curry. Everything arrived piping hot, tasted beautiful and everyone really enjoyed what they ordered. Hats off to the landlord as he was run off his feet with staff shortages and holiday cover but the staff that were there, did a grand Job. Only 3 of us managed a pudding which was 2 sticky toffee pudding with custard and a cheesecake with cream. Very well presented and tasted delicious , just as the main meals did. ,Plenty of craft beer, lager & wine to choose from with friendly staff to see to your needs. A nice big car park with outside seating and plenty of more seats at the far end of the car park. Well worth a visit, will definitely call again.
This is the best home cooked pub food, every meal is delicious and cooked to perfection. The triple cooked chips are just the best and every dish is plentiful. Would recommend it to anyone.
Had an absolutely fantastic experience here. Lovely place, well priced, brilliant staff and incredible food. Will definitely be back soon.
This place serves AMAZING food. All home-made and delicious. The cauliflower cheese is to die for, one of the best I've eaten. (My Fav food) Desserts melted in your mouth. Highly recommended. I wish I'd taken a photo but couldn't wait to tuck in 😄 service with a friendly smile and great banter. Went with big group of friends (netball team) and everyone raved about their food. Thank you 👏👏
Exception food and service
There was a large group of 14 of us, mid week
Most of us had steak pie or steak and Stilton pie. The chips are the best I’ve had in a long time.
We will definitely be going back!!
Brilliant pub great service great atmosphere and excellent food with plenty of choice.
Great value for money large portions, highly recommend the steak
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Rotherham
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes