What a great little pub. We visited on Saturday evening for a meal before my wife's triathlon. I don't think we could have had a better meal, better atmosphere or anything really. The staff and customers were friendly, accommodating and just generally a really really great pub.
The food was exceptional from the starters (biggest chicken goujons I think we have seen) to the desserts (the lightest sticky toffee I have had) and everything in between.
We will definitely be trying to visit again if are ever in the area.
Had so many bad meals recently that we were beginning to despair but The Highway Man at Sheriff Hutton has restored my faith in finding a good meal. I had the chicken supreme. The chicken was so tender and tasty. The veg was cooked to how we like it - cooked! So very good. Husband had the trio of lamb chops. Again well cooked and tender. The chips were lovely. The onion rings were beautiful. The staff are fantastic and welcoming and friendly. Brilliant. Would recommend this place to everyone. We didn’t have room for a sweet so can’t comment on them. Will have to aim for one of those!! Need to book a table as it’s very popular.
Great Sunday Lunch. Am not surprised that it was so busy. Very dog friendly, but only in the garden or the small bar - so make sure to book a table if taking your dog. Only 2 beers on hand pump - Theakstons Best Bitter and Pennine Hair Of The Dog... but good choices. We chose the small meal which was actually quite big but saw several people eating the adult size which was pretty massive. We were told the roast beef was well cooked so had pork which was excellent. All really good. Traditional puddings were also really great. Super lunch at a very reasonable price. Brisk service from a hard working and very friendly staff. Will be coming here again .
Amazing ale , I had ace ipa. Very nice. Portions are massive . You won't go hungry . Home made and. Fresh . I recommend booking in advance as it does get busy . Had the steak pie and a burger on different evenings . Both were excellent. But expect a wait as it's all cooked fresh.
We stayed at York Meadows Campsite in our campervan and had a walk ( about a mile) to this fanatstic pub. Unfortunately there was no food on at the time due to staff holidays so can not comment on the food but looking at reviews and talking to the locals in the pub it is very good indeed. The locals are very friendly and we were made very welcome and had a lovely afternoon and early evening chatting with everyone, and also people staying in the campsite who called in as well, alovely pub, highly recommend, looking forward to coming back and trying the food. They are dog friendly and our Tyler enjoyed all the attention she was getting and loved the fire :-)
Staying at caravan site nearby, and had meal for the 2 nights we've been here. Food was excellent and service great, with friendly staff. Will definately return when we are staying in the area again.
Another gem of a Village pub serving home cooked food.
Best meal all week by far and booked again for Friday.
Very busy for a Wednesday night so the locals must know something.
Best home cooked chips since my grandma so that is high praise indeed.
What a find....
We were at the Caravan and Camping Club site and walked it. Took 40 minutes with the dogs. What a great find, we loved dinner, proper home made steak and kidney and steak sn mushroom pies, seasonal veg, great plentiful gravy and nice puds to follow. My wife wants to take this place home to Lancashire. Beer was 1st class too. Can't believe anyone can give thiscless than 5 stars. We had dogs so ate in bar area which we expect and not only food but atmosphere and locals banter was great.
Called in after a visit to see the Castle ruins. Gorgeous Sunday lunch and pudding outside in the spacious rear garden.
Just called in with a friend for a drink at the Highwayman Inn at Sheriff Hutton.
Small car park at the side. Beer garden at the back suitable for families and dogs.
Oldy worldy inside and welcoming staff. A couple of locals said hello.
Make a reservation
Order online
Find the best restaurant in Sheriff Hutton
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes