Pizza Pit Extreme

I love this location compared to the lake mills one. The crew here is just so nice. Very clean store. I placed a order over the phone for pickup a few weeks ago and I spoke with amber, she was so nice and just really patient. She helped out as far as what I was looking to order and the deals that they had.. The manager I think his name was hunter, has helped out with some miscommunication as well and was super nice. Training here was done amazing. The crew is just amazing. The food is fresh and literally coming off the oven as you get there. Its a recommend. They also sell ice cream here which is a great desert for after the pizza.

Ok so nothing to special about this pizza but only pizza joint in town. Very friendly staff as always. I ordered for pick up and said pizza be ready in 35 minutes. Ok so I made it at the 40 minute mark but the pizza was cold. They didn’t keep it in a warmer or anything. On plus side I did get 4 butter garlics. It definitely disappointed me this go around. But still will order in future since only pizza place in town.

Only pizza place in town, and I watched the pizza maker make my pizza and others with no gloves. Super gross as he was touching everything. Not only is it unsanitary, but we are in a world with covid going around.. please don't handle money, phones, and make my pizza. Where gloves change gloves and wash in-between. Gross🤮

Unfortunately, there are not many food delivery options in Cambridge. One star goes to being the "only show in town" and the other star goes to the Pizzas we've ordered being generally decent. The vastly disappointing thing about this place is they have screwed up my orders 9/10 times. Every order, they forget to deliver the extra sauce I pay for. Excuses include: -Don't order online because it doesn't print everything on our slip (which is a lie - the receipt they send with the pizza always has everything they are missing on it) -We didn't see that on the slip -You don't have to pay for the extra sauce because the cheese sticks already comes with 3 cheese (then WHY wouldn't you send it with three when two extra are paid for, and, WHY don't I get more than one cheese sauce when I don't pay for extra?) Then, to be fair, I always get an apology and someone always offers to bring me what was left behind or they offer to make another pizza when they miss toppings that were added to the order. Taste: I think pizza appreciation is a very personal thing, so I wouldn't want to put someone off based on my opinion. I like pepperoni on top of cheese to be crispy, but that isn't done here. They cheese blend they use tastes great, but exudes a lot of grease that makes the crust soggy with grease. The crust: I have ordered thin, thick, and regular crust and there is ABSOLUTELY NO DIFFERENCE. Either that, or you can chuck that up to additional orders that have been screwed up in the past. Staff: Mostly friendly high-school student working part time. The adults working there seem to enjoy their job and are very pleasant. I'd love to be able to start giving these guys credit for a job well done, but frankly, I've only gotten what I ordered correctly the first time a couple times in the past 6 months.

(READ ALL THE WAY THROUGH please) I had to edit my review from this past summer. I loved the manager last year and when Pizza Pit changed management and began to service Deerfield we had a TON of mix ups and not just at Cambridge, at the Lake Mills PPit also. It was beyond a minor issue and it just wasn’t getting better, it got worse. This seemed primarily an employee issue. Since I last wrote my 1 star review, a lot has changed. The new manager has gone above and beyond. He remembers us when we call in, and is beyond kind. When we heard they had new management we gave them one last try and we haven’t been disappointed since. I really do feel like these guys worked hard to get our business back. I hope to be able to update my review again in a few months to a 5 star:) Time will tell. I applaud you Cambridge Pizza Pit. One day at a time you’re winning us over again. Keep up the good work!! Melanie

The food was good and arrived at a decent time, but the guy who delivered it threw out there that he should get a bigger tip. I threw him 5 bucks extra but found it offensive. I have every right to tip whether I have the money or not, it's not mandatory. I do not plan on tipping that guy if he ever delivers to my house again.