Gencarellis Of Lyndhurst

552 New York Ave, 07071 - Lyndhurst
Italian Pizza
★★★★★ ★★★★★
87/100
1214 recommendations

Verified Dish

Add Missing Dish

87/100
Sluurpy Score
1,214 total reviews
Tripadvisor
4.5/5
52 reviews
Google
4.4/5
360 reviews
Facebook
4.0/5
46 reviews
Grubhub
4.0/5
91 reviews
Restaurantji
4.1/5
100 reviews
Slice
5.0/5
565 reviews

Contact Information

📞 Phone: +1 201-672-0104
📍 Address: 552 New York Ave, Lyndhurst

🕐 Opening Hours

Open now Closes at 10:00 PM
Monday1 10:30 AM - 09:00 PM
Tuesday2 10:30 AM - 09:00 PM
Wednesday3 10:30 AM - 09:00 PM
Thursday4 10:30 AM - 10:00 PM
Friday5 10:30 AM - 10:00 PM
Saturday6 10:30 AM - 09:00 PM
Sunday7 10:30 AM - 09:00 PM

Google Reviews (8)

M

ManchesterUtd Fan

5 months ago
★★★☆☆ 3/5
Gencarellis has to make one of the best pizzas I’ve personally ever had. This review has NOTHING to do with the quality of the pizza. This has to do with the price/quantity of the grandma pie. AGAIN the pie was absolutely delicious, but if I’m paying $25 you better be filling that box. As you can see from the picture I posted, I will never be ordering a grandma pie again from here. No matter how good it was you aren’t getting what you pay for. I’ve ordered grandma pies at other locations and the size comparison is noticeable. Just a word of warning to anyone else interested in trying the grandma pie. Expensive and not the amount reflecting it.
Read more
Google
B

BUNDY802

7 months ago
★★★★★ 5/5
The food was very good with the exception of the fried calamari it wasn’t fresh and not fried enough.The eggplant rollatini was very good, and all of our other pasta dishes were very good as well, everything was cooked perfectly. The service was very good. Our waitress was super friendly and helpful. This is a BYOB restaurant.
Read more
Google
C

Chuck Mound

a year ago
★★★☆☆ 3/5
Scouting for the Pizza Hunters App, was one of the first customers to arrive on a Sunday. A good looking Plain Pizza just came out of the oven. A regular slice and Drink is $5.15. Good Size slice that was just your average slice. A good amount of cheese dominated the slice that did not have any sauce. Think it was more paste which does not appeal to me. The crust was ok. Good Slice that will fill your belly, but not advancing far in a Pizza Tournament. Which is fine, looks like they do well in the area. The restaurant is huge and can accommodate a large number of people. I would go back, the man at the counter was very nice and provided excellent customer service..would like to try some other slices to get a better handle on this pizzeria.
Read more
Google
J

Juanita G

a year ago
★★★★☆ 4/5
The service was a 5, excellent. The portions were huge for the price which was affordable. The bread they gave us was delicious. The rest of the food was ok. Like I said huge portions and great service. May have needed a little more flavor, but I would go back to try other dishes. They had quite a variety of items to choose from.
Read more
Google
D

Daniel L

3 months ago
★★★★★ 5/5
It may look like your average local town casual restaurant but the food is amazing! Excellent sauces, great pasta, bread is to die for. Huge portions!
Google
K

Kevin Broomell

a week ago
★★★★★ 5/5
This place is the real deal. We ordered here through grubhub for thr 1st time and man this is legit. The California cutlet sub is phenomenal. Great chicken parm. Mozz sticks very good and the kids cavetelli and broccoli was a huge portion and so tasty. Clearly homemade bread and attention to detail. I cannot wait to try their pizza. I'd give this 6 stars if I could.
Read more
Google
C

Chez Egstromlet

4 months ago
★★★★★ 5/5
Awesome! Really, really good food! Wait staff are a lot of fun and on their game! Love coming here! Especially when I want a great meal! Many thanks!
Google
C

Christopher O'Connor

a month ago
★☆☆☆☆ 1/5
Don’t use their own website. They gave me a half hour wait time. When I get there they didn’t even start preparing it. Said give them 10 minutes ok. Another 20 minutes finally done for a large pie and chicken sandwich. I get that it’s dinner time but no apology and they acted like I inconvenienced them.
Read more
Google

📊 Compare with Other Restaurants

Restaurant Score Google Tripadvisor Reviews
Lyndhurst Pastry Shop 89% 4.7/5 4.5/5 1,115
Colonial Diner 86% 4.5/5 4.5/5 3,257
Michael's Riverside 81% 4.5/5 4.5/5 953
Thistle Restaurant 82% 4.6/5 4.5/5 594
Angelo's Restaurant 83% 4.4/5 4.0/5 830
Trattoria Il Cafone 88% 4.4/5 4.5/5 417

Other Restaurants in Lyndhurst

Vinnie's Mootz

⭐ 100.0 (26 reviews)

Marina's Sandwich Shop

⭐ 100.0 (18 reviews)

Uno Chicago Grill

⭐ 100.0 (2 reviews)

A Bite In Time

⭐ 100.0 (1 reviews)

Bulldog Cafe

⭐ 100.0 (1 reviews)

Forest Edge Roasting

⭐ 99.0 (106 reviews)

Help us improve

← Back to all restaurants in Lyndhurst

🍽️ Suggest a dish

⚠️ Report error

🚫 Report closed

Do you confirm that Gencarellis Of Lyndhurst has permanently closed?