Ella-May Thornely
Came to Notty house with my housemates for pies, their pies looked amazing! Being gluten free I could only eat chips which were nice. Its only chips that get fried so they're gluten safe. It would be amazing to see some gluten free meat and vegetarian/vegan pies to be on offer, even if they're handmade and frozen, also gluten free gravy? I'd love to eat a pie !! đ„§
Paul Whittick
Well this was a great experience if you fancy a pie , staff friendly food great I would come again definitely đ ÂŁ12:50 and a hearty portion plenty to choose from on the menu as long as itâs pie with mash or chips and peas .
Katie P
The day we went the selection of pies was scarce but it just shows how popular the place is. Great crispy pie casing and the pies are always full! The chips are also nice, not greasy. The only thing was that this place was busy and staff didnât seem quick to clear tables but this is a great spot to visit otherwise. Another downside is no gluten free option, I would lobe to bring my family / friends but unable due to allergies.
Janae
Lamb mince and feta pie with mush and mushy pea. Fairly good in general but didnât meet my expectations. The seasoning is strong but kind of common, and the pastry has little sense of existence.
Worth trying when youâre lazy to cook :)
Keiran Jack
Affordable, approachable staff, possibly the best pies in Sheffield. Had chicken and chorizo and it was fab. Gravy couldâve been a tad thicker but still tasted great
Jill Lowe
Magnificent pie and chips! Today we had the Italian Stallion and Steak and Stilton pies. Really tasty pies come with a generous portion of delicious chips (mushy peas too if youâd like) and extra gravy. The staff are welcoming and helpful, with super service. I highly recommend this place, perfect for Sunday lunch!
Marc Gasp
Really appreciate the beef pie, a true pub where spend time with you affects, there's billiard table and darts to play with
D M
Not the most appealing from the outside or inside, but the atmosphere is great and, obviously appreciated by the, mostly, student clientele. The staff are really kind and caring, but the best part is the variety of pies that they provide, with chips or mash and peas. Hendersons always available. đ
MarĂa Del Amor Molina Baena
Amazing pies! Best ones I have tried in England so far. Great atmosphere, excellent food, good brews selection and attentive staff. Toilets were quite clean and tidy. We needed to wait 20 minutes for a table (they donât make any reservations) and 1h for the pies but... it was understandable as it was 1 oâclock on a Sunday. There wasnât mash, that was quite sad but the fries were AMAZING. Gravy was quite meaty so very good accompaniment. Will definitely come back :)
Paola Bravo Rivera
The best place to eat pies and chips. I ate chicken and chorizo pie and it was perfect, a good quality dough and Greta flavour. Chips are the best that I've tried, super crunchy outside and like a mash inside. Good atmosphere and beautiful place. Just the heating was almost turned off but everything was perfect
Nick Taylor
I love this place a great pub with loads of atmosphere great staff and the food is top class. You have to get there early or you may not get the pie you want.
Alan Washington
Genuine Home made pies to order. A great variety including vegetarian
Lots of chat and no TV.
Beer average.
Marija Botyriute
Superb! Tried the famous pies and was not dissapointed. Absolutely divine!!!
Caroline Pacey
Cosy atmosphere on a wet and windy day. Delicious steak and Guinness pies with pints. Very glad our four legged friend also welcome
Andrew H
We all had Steak and ale pie and chips. Pie was mint....Not one of those sparsely filled with grisly meat jobbies. This one was perfect, packed with tender lean meat chunks and proper aley gravy. It was big too.
The chips..praise be! They were actually identifiable as being cut from a bone fide real potato, rather than icy, reformed, zombie chips shaken from a McCain bag or summat.
Didn't have mushy peas as I don't like them. Think the chef gave us extra chips in lieu.
Abbeydale pale ale was decent also.
Only gripe was the table needed a wipe when we sat down. They were quite busy though.
Steve L
Really excellent pub in Sheffield. Probably the best pies in the city I reckon. Friendly staff too. Great collecting of vegan and veggie pies too.
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes