Silver Lining Diner

Do not be fooled, this restaurant is only a diner in name and design. On my most recent visit I ordered the fried seafood platter and a side salad. I half expected the diner version of seafood deluxe what I received was far and away the best fried seafood platter I’ve had on Long Island. The scallops were super fresh, calamari was tender and the fries tasted like potato not freezer. Layer in the little extra touches like lots of fresh lemon, a homemade tarter sauce that had real flavor and a few sprigs of deep fried parsley leaves made this dish a home run. Service was wonderful, cheery, quick to laugh and super informative about the menus. All in this is the place you’ve been looking for.

So this place is usually from what I see very packed, drove by on our way to Hanks Pumpkin Town looked cool decided to check it out after. As soon as you walk in it's not your typical diner. It's Chic, funky, retro and vibrant. That yellow is a signature look. Staff is very friendly but the wait was e4xtremely long and for that it is the only reason I gave a 4 Star. Once we received our starters it was amazing freshly made humus work warm pita bread, fresh made lemonade... The soup of the day clam chowder, YUMMY with a hint of bacon.... Main selection was the Salomon it was moist and delicious esp paired with the Lentils was perfect.

We visited on Labor Day weekend and had a great experience. Jerome our server was excellent as were the French toast, eggs and bacon we ordered. Food was fresh and delicious, especially the blueberries. We were told we would have a 15 minute wait, but we were texted in 4 minutes and seated in a nice large booth. The decor is light and airy and the bathrooms are spotless. We went back on Monday for lunch which was also great! So glad someone turned this place into a great option for casual dining in Southampton. Thank you!

After a long drive, we stopped at the Silver Lining Diner for a break and a bite to eat. Are we ever glad we did! We ordered margaritas and an order of chips and guacamole. The margarita was delicious, hit the spot and I felt the vacation was starting. Guacamole was delicious and chips fresh and crisp, I highly recommend. I ordered the striped bass special. Beautifully prepared fish and it came with roasted potato wedges. We loved our server, Scott - he was super friendly. I like the look of the place, cheerful and fun. This place is our new family tradition!

Great design. Modern and retro at the same time. Not a regular diner menu but does have regular diner faire. Large portions and uniquely presented dishes. The only reason it is 4 stars and not 5 is that it is Southampton expensive. Wait staff was fantastic even though it was very busy. Definitely recommend.

On our way out of town we stopped for a quick bite!!! Surprised and delighted!!! 1.ambience was perfect. Fun, clean and just a great feeling. 2. Amazing food!!! Best Caesar salad, guacamole and a clever tasty lobster/pasta dish!! 3. Service friendly, fast and treated like royalty! See you next week!!! Count me in as a new regular!

The quality of the food here is AMAZING. The Greek salad, French fries, fluke, brisket, chicken wings, and frozen custard were the best I’ve ever had. The restaurant is also beautiful inside. As if all that weren’t enough, the owners are wonderful people. Hallelujah - an amazing year round restaurant in the hamptons!!!

So happy this place has been reopened!! What an asset! I swore the spot off 13 years ago when the food was so awful I was convinced it was deliberate. When I drove past and saw the place open, full of people yet still plenty of parking I raced to Springs to take care of business and got back ASAP....delish. So far I have left Springs to eat there 3 times...and currently plotting my next meal. Get the pastrami!! Get the wedge!! Have a burger!! The shrimp cocktail is amazing! And dessert — So glad the days of display case pie are over... So happy Silver Lining Diner has opened!