Sheldon's Ice Cream

Best Ice Cream around! The location isn't the best, but if you're willing to drive a little you won't be disappointed. We try to visit with the kids once a month and we're always trying something new because everything ends up being amazing. Plus they sell soft serve in a variety of flavors which is great since not many places have it at all anymore.

Nice little spot, delicious homemade ice cream with SO many flavors, not just the usual ones either. My son had "Cookie monster" ‐ blue vanilla with cookie dough and oreos, and loved it. I'm a fan of anything S'mores so I had try theirs. (It did not disappoint!) Should have ordered kid size, regular cone was 2 big scoops on top so generous portions. They had multiple vegan and gluten free options as well. FYI it's cash only

I think this place is exceptionally good! We got some ice cream and it tasted really good! I like that it’s next to a brook and you can sit on the deck right over it. I got raspberry with chocolate chips and my wife got chocolate peanut butter ice cream. She liked mine a lot. I like that it’s not crowded.

Our first time to Sheldon's Ice Cream and it did not disappoint! Being vegan can be hard finding sweet treats for my family, so when we were on Happy Cow (vegan food finder) I saw Sheldon's had Non Dairy Ice Cream with a bunch of different flavors not just 2 or 3. I got the mint chocolate chip and it was divine, it was minty and creamy and I can't wait to go back for more! Hubby got Cherry Bear Chocolate Chip and he loved it. My daughter (5) just waking up from a nap (long car ride) squealed with delight that they had Chocolate marshmallow and after tasting it she said it was amazing!! Highly recommend Sheldon's and we'll definitely be making the trip back up from CT regularly! Thank you for making our non dairy ice cream experience wonderful and for having creamy delicious ice cream!