The Secret Italian

The Secret Italian, Barnsley McLintock Way - Barnsley

Italian
• Mediterranean
• European
• Sit down

99/100
Recommended by 74 people
Give a rating

What's your favorite The Secret Italian's dish?

Ratings and reviews

99
/100
Based on 5367 ratings and reviews
Updated

Ratings of The Secret Italian

TA

Trip
Last update on 08/11/2023
5,0
515 Reviews
Google
Google
Last update on 15/11/2023
4,8
191 Reviews
Facebook
Facebook
Last update on 03/11/2022
4,9
240 Reviews

RG

Restaurant guru
Last update on 06/10/2022
5,0
601 Reviews

S

Sluurpy
Last update on 25/11/2021
5,0
3760 Reviews

Reviews

5
Tracy Ullyott
+5
Me and my partner were lucky enough to get a cancellation. I'd heard about it and read the reviews so we were looking forward to it and we were not disappointed! My partner is a vegetarian and it's a set menu so he was a bit apprehensive. However, he enjoyed every single dish and so did I...could not fault anything! The dessert is a Tiramisu and I've never been a fan but I have to say that was one of the best desserts I've ever had! The service was outstanding from start to finish,especially Jana who cooked and spoke to every customer in between...she is amazing!
5
Charmaine Eyre
+5
Been here quite a few times, and still going back , the hosts Margaret and Jan are very friendly, nothing is too much trouble, the food is tiramisu is to die for
5
Chris Peat
+5
Our first time here and what a gem of a restaurant, the Valentine's menu was delicious, 6 starters before the main meal and then the desserts. All the food had so many flavours, we were Absolutely stuffed. You won't be disappointed with this Italian. Margaret and Jana are so welcoming. Many thanks Chris & Allison.
5
Andrew Beever
+5
Very good food and plenty of it. Be aware that it's a set menu, although Margaret does contact you to ask if there are any dietary requirements. Remember it is unlicensed so take your own drinks 🍷
5
Julie Rogerson
+5
This place is so so lovely the meal was amazing. 9 courses of fabulous food. Cooked fresh while you were there. The staff are brilliant. Margaret the owner she just makes you feel so welcome. It was an amazing night for my birthday. Thankyou xx
5
Chris Hilton
+5
Wow. The best dining experience. The food is fantastic and Claudia/Margaret are amazing. We will definitely be booking back in. The only down side is that it is so long before we can go back.
5
Brett Hatfield
+5
I heard about this little place from a relative, he suggested a visit. So we went in, astounding! The food was all freshly prepared, wonderful, authentic Italian, I have traveled Italy from the top to bottom, it took Me back. I will definitely be returning. You definitely need a big appetite! Margaret and her Team are so very welcoming. Give it a go.
5
Stu Taylor
+5
Thus place is fantastic. For £27.50 you get a set menu, which for us was anti-pasti consisting of bruscetta, meatballs, borloti beans, garlic mushrooms, Mozzarella and salami. Followed by two different spaghetti dishes, then chicken and roast potatoes and veg, and finally the most delicious tiramisu. Unfortunately I didn't manage to take too many photos, as the food was so amazing we were tucking in before we even thought to reach for the camera. The place is very small so the atmosphere is amazing, the owners are real characters and make the evening so entertaining that you don't realise just how much time you are there. Just got back in and already trying to book our next visit.
5
Josh Ingamells
+5
Food and service was excellent. Fantastic night out, amazing value. Couldn’t recommend enough. Course after course of amazing food.
4
Jimmy Harley
+4
Enjoyable family meal out, a very cosy (little) restaurant, friendly staff. Did feel a little underwhelmed by the main dish which was 2 chicken thighs, some potatoes and broccoli, feel like this is the main part of the menu that could be improved. Felt like it needed an accompaniment such as a sauce or something.

Timetable

Monday:
Closed
Tuesday:
Wednesday:
07:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Thursday:
07:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Friday:
07:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Saturday:
07:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Sunday:
Closed

Read the reviews on

TA

Trip
Google
Google
Facebook
Facebook

RG

Restaurant guru

Info

Compare the best restaurants near The Secret Italian

Our aggregate rating, “Sluurpometro”, is 99 based on 5367 parameters and reviews

If you need to contact by phone, call the number +44 1226 244888

MAKE A QUESTION

SUBMIT
1