George's Sub & Pizza Shop

George's has been a Carlisle staple for many years with many loyal customers. For me it's a restaurant of 2 eras. The food was spectacular when the restaurant was ran by the father George. Great atmosphere. Friendly staff. Good prices and portions. I'm not saying the son's who run it now aren't great in their own right but it's not the same as back then. Food is good but not as good. I don't frequent nearly as much but it is still a good choice for subs and burgers. Pretty good food. Atmosphere is nice but as I stated I don't frequent much as before. They do have delivery and pick up which is great for the times we live in presently.

Place was very neat and clean, the staff was friendly and helpful. The fries were about the best I have ever had. Crispy on outside and tasty. Also not too salty. The cheesesteaks were loaded nicely, and the bread delicious. The pizza was good. My only quibble is I wish they had some pasta. Could they keep a pan of lasagna or some baked ziti around?

There's gotta be some special ingredient that makes George's pizza better than any other pizza. And I realize that I'm probably committing an 8th deadly sin here, but George's milkshakes far surpass the PA farm show ones in both thickness and flavor! Even though the food is amazing, the best part of George's may be the customer service, friendliness, and generosity of the people who work there. (Though I'm still a little bitter that you took my picture down during the renovation and haven't put it back up yet. I'll try not to hold it against you for too long! 😜)

Fantastic pizza!! The Supreme was incredible and the sauce is the best I've ever had, with a fantastic combination of herbs and spices. The White pizza was absolutely perfect too, with just the right amount of broccoli, garlic, and the ideal blend of white cheeses. Great take out service. Definitely worth the price!!

We just moved to Carlisle boro and received a menu in the mail advertising "WE DELIVER!" We called at 7:45 on a Saturday night to order some pizza and Stromboli. We were quickly told that they DO NOT actually deliver.... So we said we'd come pick it up. We were then informed that they don't make any pizzas or Strombolis after 8pm..... First, it was 7:45. Second, why would you stop making your main menu items a hour before you close???? Makes zero sense to me. I get that times have been tough for eateries, maybe they're under staffed? But don't send advertisements out saying you deliver when you don't. And don't turn away business over a hour before you close! If we had called at 8:50 I could understand. But sheesh, it's a Saturday night in a college town. Shutting down your kitchen at 7:45 makes no sense. We threw the menu away and went to Miseno.