Humble Pie 'n' Mash

After watching Gary Eats on YouTube, I wanted to give this place a go. Inside is very quaint, we managed to grab a seat before it got full thankfully. I got the chicken and leek pie which was probably the best chicken and leek pie I have had, it went very well with the mash and gravy. I definitely recommend!

A really cozy & interesting place to eat, looking at all the old items found in the building. It was a nice change from all the fish & chip shops. Staff were lovely and service super quick. The portion sizes were generous & tasted so nice! Would definitely recommend, I would visit again in the future!

Loved it, good wholesome freshly made food Quaint olde cafe, with odd tables with plastic tablecloth, odd chairs and benches, original old working fire range that was warm and cosy. The waiter was friendly and polite and seemed to really enjoy his job. The food was amazing, vegan mushroom and ale pie was delicious. Steak and ale pie, I was told was outstanding. The roasted veg and chickpea also very highly rated, all with peas and mash and lovely gravy. A real gem and alternative to fish and chips. Definitely worth a visit.

Interesting restaurant al based around its own amazing history and set up like a war time cafe. We had the Goats Cheese and veg pie and the chicken leek pie which were both delicious. Big servings and very filling and a good price too. I’d definitely recommend a visit here as the food was great. Only marked it down as the young lad serving dis-interested and bored and came across as quite rude.

Went to Whitby for the day and had decided to go here before we set off as my partner had been before. Turned up, one table free and the waiter made it suit the 3 of us. Ordered and food arrived quickly. We all had pie, mash and peas. My creamy chicken and leek pie was very good, really tasty. I have been to other 1940s cafes and would say this one lacks a bit of 1940s atmosphere, very basic decor. Would definitely go back though.