🔍 Toastie ✕

Best Toastie in Sheffield

The 16 best places to eat toastie in Sheffield: verified reviews, photos and ratings. Updated September 2026.

🍴

20

Cuisine Types

16 of 16 restaurants

Sort: ⭐ Top Rated 💬 Popular 💰 ↑ 💰 ↓

Endcliffe Park Cafe

Endcliffe Park Cafe

£ 💬 7680 reviews

📍 Endcliffe Park Rustlings Road

The Treehouse Board Game Cafe

The Treehouse Board Game Cafe

££ - £££ 💬 7421 reviews

📍 41 Boston Street

Aesthete Coffee + Kitchen

Aesthete Coffee + Kitchen

££ - £££ 💬 745 reviews

📍 348-352 South Road

Howst

££ - £££ 💬 3055 reviews

📍 46 Howard Street

True Loves

££ - £££ 💬 570 reviews

📍 Arch 19 Victoria Quays Wharf Street

Caffe Nero

££ - £££ 💬 1328 reviews

📍 2 High Street

Woodland Coffee Stop

Woodland Coffee Stop

££ - £££ 💬 540 reviews

📍 Ecclesall Woods

Lisboa Cafe & Patisserie (crookes)

Lisboa Cafe & Patisserie (crookes)

££ - £££ 💬 497 reviews

📍 238 Crookes

Costa Coffee

£ 💬 731 reviews

📍 Bochum Parkway

Couch

Cafe British International

££ - £££ 💬 1231 reviews

📍 29-31 Campo Lane

Caffe Nero

£ 💬 1385 reviews

📍 St. Pauls Place 121 Norfolk Street

Greggs

💬 136 reviews

📍 Meadowhall Retail Park Drive Thru

The Horse & Jockey

The Horse & Jockey

££ - £££ 💬 1146 reviews

📍 250 Wadsley Lane

Costa Coffee

£ 💬 3681 reviews

📍 89 Pinstone Street

Costa Coffee

💬 631 reviews

📍 2-3 Orchard Square

Hare And Hounds Pub

Hare And Hounds Pub

Bar British Pub

££ - £££ 💬 967 reviews

📍 1-7 Church Lane

🍴

Explore by Cuisine Type

British 371 Cafe 205 Pub 198 Bar 194 Fast food 143 Asian 122 Pizza 102 Indian 87 Italian 87 American 78 Chinese 68 European 55 Mediterranean 47 Balti 39 Middle Eastern 34 Seafood 30 Bangladeshi 24 Turkish 21 Grill 20 Mexican 20

Why Trust Sluurpy

Aggregated and verified data from multiple sources

📊

0 Reviews Analyzed

🏆

0 Top Restaurants

📋

0 Browsable Menus

📅

Sep 2026 Last Updated